I went into Shaman's Cave on some other quests and went all the way up to Red Eye, soloing him quite easily. I left the cave and picked up the Signs of Danger quest later, so I head back in to search for Ellie. Problem is, I already cleared the cave, Red Eye is still dead, and there's no sign of this Ellie. The quest giver still doesn't allow me to complete it, and the quest log displays Red Eye's status as "Alive".
Anyone else having this issue? Seems to be a bug in which if you kill Red Eye first, then pick up the quest, the quest doesn't register that he's already dead.